Blue Moon Ice Cream Recipe

What gives Blue Moon ice cream its distinctive flavor is not fully understood. The majority of us will need to make an educated guess based on the taste, but there is some clue that can help us decipher the mysterious sweet. Researchers have likened the ethereal blue color to Froot Loops cereal, vanilla, marshmallows, and bubble gum. Other comparisons have been made between vanilla, marshmallows, raspberry, and lemon found in this mysterious ice cream.

Bill Sidon, who worked as the chief flavor chemist for Petran Products in Milwaukee during the 1950s, is credited with developing the first recipe for Blue Moon. The flavor immediately became ingrained in the Midwestern states’ tradition of serving ice cream. Today, several regional creameries make this well-known ice cream, but they do not disclose the recipes for their proprietary products. Visit the official website of Petran Products and begin browsing around the site to acquire additional information regarding the recipe.

What is Blue Moon Ice Cream?

Regarding the taste of blue moon, there is no unambiguous response available. Tasters might find it to be reminiscent of this or that, but there are some widely held beliefs about what it might be. Fans of blue moon often point to the taste of Froot Loops—the breakfast cereal—as one of the primary components of the beer’s overall flavor profile.

There are many other possible flavors, such as vanilla with a hint of citrus, amaretto, lemon, cotton candy, marshmallow, bubble gum, and more. Raspberry and lemon are the two ingredients needed to make blue moon ice cream at home. We apologize for the inconvenience. The trademarked recipe has been guarded against public disclosure since it was first developed. You would be, in all likelihood, out of luck unless you worked as a flavor chemist at Petran Products in Milwaukee, the company that is credited with inventing this flavor. Petran Products is located in Wisconsin.

What does Blue Moon Ice Cream Taste Like?

A fruity flavor characterizes it, and some people have compared it to the taste of the milk that is left over after finishing a bowl of Fruit Loops or Fruity Pebbles. In addition, it has been said that it tastes like cotton candy, bubble gum, or even a flavor that is hard to explain! It may seem strange to your ears but trust us: it’s wonderful.

Blue Moon Ice Cream Recipe

Blue moon ice cream is one of the most distinctive flavors in the United States, and blue moon ice cream is most commonly located in the upper Midwest region. It is said to have originated in Milwaukee, located in Wisconsin, and is distinguished by its brilliant blue color. The flavor is unique and is produced by combining extracts of vanilla bean, raspberry flavoring made from artificial raspberries, and lemon extract.

Some people have described the flavor as having a “tutti-frutti” quality, while others have compared it to cotton candy, bubble gum, Fruit Loops or Fruity Pebbles. Naturally, blue food coloring increases until the color reaches the desired intensity. You can easily make your own blue moon ice cream at home with the help of an ice cream maker, even though it is typically only available in ice cream shops in the Midwest.


  • Two large egg yolks
  • 1/2 cup sugar
  • 2 cups of full-fat cream
  • 1 cup of undiluted milk
  • One tablespoon of instant vanilla pudding mix
  • 1 milligram of raspberry flavoring, a teaspoon
  • 1 milligram of lemon extract in a teaspoon
  • 1/2 teaspoon pure vanilla extract

How to Make Blue Moon Ice Cream?

  • Egg yolks and a cup of sugar should be softly beaten together in a medium basin and then left aside.
  • In a medium pot, add cream, milk, and remaining sugar. Stirring the mixture periodically while heating it over medium-low heat until bubbles start to develop around the pan’s edges is the process to follow. Take the pan from the heat and, while whisking continually, gradually add the warm cream mixture to the eggs, one tablespoon at a period. This will temper the eggs.
  • After combining the cream mixture and the eggs, transfer the mixture back into the saucepan and continue heating it over medium-low heat until it coats the back of a spoon or spatula and a line traced with a finger leaves a clear trail. The temperature of the combination should read between 170 and 175 degrees Fahrenheit (77 and 79 degrees Celsius), but you should not let it get too hot.
  • After pouring the custard into a medium bowl, stir in the vanilla pudding mix until it is completely combined with the custard. The raspberry flavoring, lemon oil, and vanilla extract should be mixed using a whisk until well combined.
  • Place bowl over a container containing ice. After one hour of letting the mixture cool at room temperature and stirring it regularly, transfer it to the refrigerator, cover it, and let it sit there for two hours or up to an entire night until it is cooled. Turn the cooled custard in your ice cream maker following the manufacturer’s directions.
  • Place the ice cream in a dish or storage container containing one quart. Cover and place in the freezer for at least three hours so it can be completely set. 

What Flavor is Blue Moon Ice Cream?

The ice cream has been characterized as having a “Smurf-blue, marshmallow-sweet” flavor by the Chicago Tribune. In certain areas, the Superman ice cream package includes a scoop of Blue Moon ice cream as one of the component flavors.

There is a very solid reason why blue moon taste has always been thought of as a mysterious flavor. It isn’t easy to pinpoint exactly what the taste is, and the recipe might differ depending on who makes the ice cream.

After trying the recipe with raspberry and lemon taste, I have to say that I do not agree with the common belief that blue moon ice cream has an almond flavor. There are a lot of people who hold this belief.

Is Blue Moon Just Vanilla?

Fans of blue moon often point to the taste of Froot Loops—the breakfast cereal—as one of the primary components of the beer’s overall flavor profile. There are many other possible flavors, such as vanilla with a hint of citrus, amaretto, lemon, cotton candy, marshmallow, bubble gum, and more. Raspberry and lemon are the two ingredients needed to make blue moon ice cream at home.

What Kind of Material Constitutes a Blue Moon?

Malted barley, white wheat, orange peel, coriander, and oats are all part of the grain bill for Blue Moon. The beer is traditionally served with a slice of orange, which the brewers at Blue Moon claim brings out the beer’s flavor even more. The alcohol content of Blue Moon, which comes in cans, bottles, and even kegs, is 5.4 percent by volume.

Is it Safe to Give Dogs Blue Moon Ice Cream?

Vanilla ice cream is one of the safest flavors to share, but due to the high amount of sugar it contains, even individuals who can digest dairy products should only consume it once in a while. Unfortunately, the fact that you are giving your dog a low-sugar variety will not improve the situation. Their vast preponderance contains artificial sweeteners, some toxic to dogs, such as xylitol.

Is there Almond Flavoring in Blue Moon Ice Cream?

As well as the steps that need to be taken to create it on our own at home. If you ask at least six different people what flavor Blue Moon ice cream is, you will receive at least six different descriptions. It smells like almonds, raspberries, lemons, Froot Loops, cotton candy, and beaver musk additive (yes, this is a real thing; more later).

Does Blue Moon Ice Cream have Pineapple?

Cotton candy, frosting, bubblegum, peeps, gin, and blue curacao? What about vanilla, pistachio, amaretto, almond, coconut, nutmeg, Pineapple, cantaloupe, raspberry, ginger, lemon, licorice, and the milk that’s left over after you’ve finished a bowl of Froot Loops, Fruity Pebbles, Trix, cotton candy, frosting, bubblegum, peeps.


The mystery surrounding the origin of this flavor of ice cream dates back decades. The flavor has a strong following in the Midwest and can be found in various Superman-themed ice creams. It is unknown where it came from, but the original recipe calls for blue moon ice cream to be combined with another flavor of ice cream. Ingredients used can differ from one manufacturer to the next in this product. You can search the soil for more information about this delectable frozen treat.

Can infer the weird taste of the ice cream from its bluish hue, which serves as a hint. It has a flavor resembling bubble gum, citrus, vanilla, and almond extract. It has an unmistakably fruity flavor, but the specific flavors are hard to pin down. It is one of the most highly sought-after ice creams worldwide, but the recipe for making it is a closely guarded secret. In addition, the taste is renowned for being one of a kind because it is created using k-lime and the pelvis of a beaver.