How to Make Brown Sugar?

Brown sugar, a less refined version of common granulated white sugar, has molasses for flavor and color. In general, it will increase the moisture in baked meals, but it may also change the color or texture of the final product. Given that it tastes well and has a strong flavor, brown sugar is a great commodity to have on hand. Use our recipe to make delicious brown sugar rapidly when you run out. All that is required to make brown sugar is to introduce molasses back into the white sugar once the refining process has been reversed. Making your own has the added benefit of enabling you to produce precisely what you require when you require it.Brown Sugar

Although brown sugar can typically be substituted for white sugar 1:1, you should be mindful that molasses may alter the final product’s color and flavor. Brown sugar is no healthier than white sugar and has a comparable number of calories, even though molasses contains considerable amounts of protein, potassium, manganese, and vitamin B6. They both offer the same volume of nutrition. A food product, including sugar, is better off the less processed it is.

What is Brown Sugar?

Brown sugar has a distinctive color and flavor because it is formed of crystalline sucrose mixed with molasses. It is produced in the Caribbean, Brazil, Australia, Europe, South Africa, and portions of the United States, among other important sugar-producing regions. Because it gives baked items a rich sweetness, brown sugar is frequently used. Additionally, it is utilized in cuisines, such as in glazes for savory foods and sweet sauces.

Typically, brown sugar rather than raw sugar is used in baking recipes (Sugar in the Raw is a popular brand name). While raw sugar and refined sugar are brown, raw sugar is often lighter and more golden. While molasses is added to white sugar to create brown sugar, molasses from the refining process is still present in raw sugar. Raw sugar often has larger sucrose crystals and a dryer texture than refined sugar. Examples of natural brown sugar variations include turbinado, muscovado, and demerara.

How to Make Brown Sugar?

Brown sugar can be used straight from the package without further processing. Pack the brown sugar firmly into the measuring cup or spoon when measuring it. Otherwise, it isn’t easy to measure precisely due to the additional moisture. Furthermore, it is lighter than most raw sugar but heavier than white sugar. One cup weighs 220 grams when measured in terms of weight (white sugar is 200 grams and raw sugar is 250 grams).

Usually, it is combined with the other ingredients in the dish. Brown sugar and white sugar are combined in a few baked goods recipes, many of which are for cookies. To make candies or glazes, brown sugar can also be cooked on the stovetop. For this, you’ll frequently use low heat to prevent burning while stirring the substance into a liquid until it dissolves.



  • 1 cup sugar, granulated (200g)
  • Two teaspoons of unsulfured molasses instead of 1 teaspoon
  • If you want to make dark brown sugar, use molasses.


  1. In a mixing basin, combine molasses and sugar.
  2. To combine the components as much as possible, use a spatula. Any lumps can be removed by smashing them with the spatula against the bowl’s side.
  3. Mix the brown sugar until there are no lumps and it has a consistent color.
  4. Use an airtight container for storage.

Brown Sugar Substitute

All of us have been there. When you go for the brown sugar bag to finish a recipe (maybe chocolate chip cookies), you realize you are completely out. Granulated sugar can be used instead, but it won’t taste the same. Your recipe will lose some moisture and not have the same depth of flavor. You’re lucky if you have molasses and normal (granulated) sugar on hand.

I’ll demonstrate how to manufacture brown sugar using only these two items (it takes less than 5 minutes). This is the real deal, the genuine article you can use in any recipe; it is not just a brown sugar alternative. This recipe is perfect for creating ahead of time and putting it in your cupboard as a backup. Try it in my brown sugar cookies or brown butter chocolate chip cookies.

What Causes Brown Sugar to Harden?

Brown sugar is hardened by air. Be careful to eliminate as much air as possible from the container you’re storing it in to keep it soft. Because it’s simple to squeeze out most of the air, I like to use a Ziploc bag. When storing in a separate container (such as a Tupperware container), pressing a piece of plastic wrap against the sugar’s surface before covering the container with a lid can be useful. Brown sugar hardens when exposed to air, unlike other sugars. This occurs due to the molasses losing moisture, which causes the sugar crystals to clump together.

If you bake, you probably already know that brown sugar sometimes crystallizes into tough pieces that are challenging to break apart. Brown sugar hardens when exposed to air, unlike other sugars. This occurs due to the molasses losing moisture, which causes the sugar crystals to clump together. So, whether stored in an open bag or an airtight container, it’ll probably turn into a rock. So, whether stored in an open bag or an airtight container, it’ll probably turn into a rock. Fortunately, there are a few quick fixes you may try so you can keep making those traditional brown sugar pastries.

Storage Tip

To maintain its moisture content, brown sugar must be stored in an airtight container. It might get harder when air exposure as the wetness gradually dries up. Although you can alternatively put the opened item in a plastic zip-top bag, some individuals prefer canisters. The brown sugar doesn’t have a shelf life as long as it is kept in proper storage, though the quality is optimum when utilized within two years.

Hardened brown sugar can be softened by including a piece of bread, a few marshmallows, or an apple wedge in the container and carefully sealing it. The sugar will become soft again in a few hours after the molasses has absorbed some of the moisture.

What does it Taste Like?

In general, brown sugar has a toffee or crystallized molasses flavor. While light brown sugar is gentler and less flavorful, dark brown sugar frequently resembles caramel and has a strong molasses flavor. You can swap out white sugar for brown sugar because they are equally sweet. But. You could notice a change in the flavor of your recipe since brown sugar has a somewhat distinct flavor than white sugar, as we explained above. Compared to refined cane sugar, dark brown sugar has a greater molasses content of roughly 6.5 percent. Due to the higher molasses content, the finished product has a rich, almost bitter, complex flavor resembling toffee and is deep, warm brown.

Brown sugar has a slightly lower calorific value than white sugar because it contains molasses and water. Brown sugar and white sugar are not interchangeable since white sugar is sweeter. Brown sugar does include some minerals due to its molasses content, most notably calcium, potassium, iron, and magnesium (white sugar contains none of these). But utilizing brown sugar has no significant health benefits because these minerals are only present in trace levels.

Can you Make Brown Sugar from White Sugar?

To create a brown sugar alternative that will trick even the most discerning palate, combine 1 cup (200 grams) of granulated white sugar with one tablespoon (15 ml) of pure maple syrup. Increase the amount of molasses to 2 tablespoons for 1 cup of granulated sugar to create dark brown sugar from white sugar. Keep in an airtight container after stirring with a fork. Add one tablespoon of molasses to 1 cup of light brown sugar to convert it to dark brown sugar. If you don’t have molasses on hand, you may easily substitute maple syrup in its place with hardly any impact on the outcome of your dish.

Using granulated white sugar as a substitute for brown sugar may be the simplest option. Replace 1 cup of white sugar with 1 cup of packed brown sugar. Just remember that the texture of baked foods will change since brown sugar adds moisture (like your cookies being crisper). In a mixing basin, combine molasses and sugar. Rub the molasses into the sugar with your fingertips until all of it is mixed and the sugar turns brown. Keep for months in an airtight container.

Is Brown Sugar Healthier than White Sugar?

They are identical in terms of nutrition besides these obtrusive variations. Their taste and color are the key variations between them. Compared to white sugar, brown sugar has more minerals and fewer calories. However, there are few nutritional differences between the two. A healthier alternative to processed white sugar is undoubtedly brown sugar. To preserve as much of the sugarcane’s natural nutrition, including vitamins and minerals, as possible, it is treated entirely naturally.

If you want to reduce sugar intake, some alternatives can be a great decision. When calorie content is considered, brown sugar is a superior option for weight loss because it has a lower calorie count than white sugar. Honey, maple syrup, jaggery, and stevia are all excellent choices for weight loss. For baking recipes that call for a deeper taste or a more moist and chewy texture, brown sugar may be preferable over white sugar. In these circumstances, muscovado sugar has the strongest flavor due to its increased molasses concentration.


Brown sugar is the gooey, aromatic sweetener that gives our favorite baked products, including banana bread and chocolate chip cookies, moisture and taste. Brown sugar is just regular granulated sugar that has been improved with molasses, even though we frequently think of them as two wholly separate things. The good news is that you probably already have everything you need to create brown sugar from scratch if you find yourself staring into an empty box.

Therefore, you need two components to make brown sugar at home, regardless of whether you need a cup, a pound, light, or dark. Here’s a recipe for it. If you do this, it won’t dry out and crystalize in your pantry. When using brown sugar for the first time, it is advised to start slowly and add more as necessary. Remember that the flavor increases stronger the darker the sugar is tinted.