Best Thanksgiving Pie Recipes

Thanksgiving is the biggest day of the year, and the best Thanksgiving pie recipes will make your holiday a hit with the whole family. If you’re new to making pies, you’ll be happy to hear that there are many recipes for no-bake pies available. Here are a few simple ideas. Using a pre-made crumb crust is a great way to start. Or you can choose a recipe that requires no baking at all. If you’re preparing large Thanksgiving dinner, a big batch of Thanksgiving pie is an excellent option. This recipe is designed to feed 24 people and is ideal for holiday gatherings.

For the best results, you should use a 13×9-inch baking pan. If you’re serving a small pie, a smaller pie is fine as well. However, if you’re making a larger pie, you should use a larger baking pan. Choosing a single-serving pie for your Thanksgiving meal is an excellent option for a holiday. You can choose a single-serving or multi-dish pie. There are many other types of Thanksgiving pie, but if you’re in a pinch, consider a fruit-based one. Combining a tart cranberry and a sweet cherry is a great way to celebrate the season with family and friends.

thanksgiving pie recipes

If you’re a novice baker, the best Thanksgiving pie recipe is the one that can be made a week in advance. You can take a few steps to get a delicious dessert in the oven. Some of the best Thanksgiving pie recipes combine different flavors and ingredients. For example, you can make a pumpkin pie with pecans or an apple pie with cranberries. Whatever you choose, it’s sure to be a hit!

Pies are an excellent choice for a holiday gathering. Depending on your taste and your guests’ preferences, you can make them sweet or savory. Fruit pies are a great option if you’re looking for something light. You can make a cranberry cherry pie if you’d prefer a tart, tangy cranberry flavor, and sweet cherries. If you’re worried about calories, try cranberry and cherry pie instead.

What Should Be On Every Thanksgiving Table?

Roast turkey, turkey stuffing, mashed potatoes, gravy, green beans, corn, dinner rolls, cranberry sauce, and pumpkin pie make up a traditional Thanksgiving supper. The traditional Thanksgiving feast comprises turkey, gravy, stuffing, potatoes, vegetables, and pie, perennial favorites. However, due to shifting cuisine trends and dietary requirements, the way these foods are prepared or added is constantly changing.

Top Six Thanksgiving Pie Recipes

  • Honey Pie
  • Toffee Almond Pie
  • Butternut Squash Pie
  • Cranberry Apple Slab Pie
  • Sweet Potato Sour Cream Pie
  • Gingersnap Cranberry Lime Pie

If you’re hosting a Thanksgiving gathering, a large batch of Thanksgiving pie will be perfect. This pie recipe serves twenty-four people and is perfect for holiday get-togethers. It’s best to use a deep-dish baking pan for a bigger pie, which will help you achieve golden-brown results. It’s also topped with candied lemon slices, which are a must-try for the ultimate Thanksgiving dessert.

1. Honey Pie

The creamy custard in this pie is infused with honey, making it a delightfully distinct yet equally delectable dessert.

Custard pies are easy to make, smooth, and delicious. I like how this dish uses honey for a unique twist. Serve with a dollop of whipped cream and a few honey-glazed walnuts if you think you’ll need some more texture.

2. Toffee Almond Pie

With its crunchy top and creamy middle, pecan pie is usually a favorite during the holidays.

This pie contains the same textures as the previous one and a similar filling. The main distinction is that almonds are used. Unlike pecans, which have a pronounced crunch, each bite of sliced almonds has a delightfully crunchy feel. And I’m all for including toffee bits into the pie filling.

3. Butternut Squash Pie

As we get closer to the holidays, switching to butternut squash instead of (or in addition to) pumpkin is a beautiful change. Although the flavors are comparable, butternut squash is more widely available. Plus, you won’t have to cook a whole pumpkin puree for a single pie! Serve with whipped cream or an ice cream scoop.

4. Cranberry Apple Slab Pie

As we get closer to the holidays, switching to butternut squash instead of (or in addition to) pumpkin is a beautiful change.

Although the flavors are comparable, butternut squash is more widely available. Plus, you won’t have to cook a whole pumpkin puree for a single pie; serve with whipped cream or an ice cream scoop.

5. Sweet Potato Sour Cream Pie

For the most part, sweet potato, pumpkin, and squash pies have comparable flavors. Some purists may object, but I consider them interchangeable. The fact that sweet potatoes are so simple to prepare is one of the reasons I choose them. Cook it until it’s tender, wrapped in foil. Scoop out the flesh and purée it, and you’re ready to go. Sour cream, like cheesecake, will smooth out the filling and give the whole pie a lovely tang.

6. Gingersnap Cranberry Lime Pie

This isn’t your average holiday table pie, but it should be. It has a lot of taste and is very stunning.

The crust is made with a combination of gingersnaps, walnuts, butter, and brown sugar and does not require rolling, and it’s as simple as pressing it into the pie plate and baking it for 12-15 minutes.

You’ll need to make a cranberry preserve for the filling by boiling fresh cranberries with sugar and water. A blender combines the cooled preserves with a lime, sugar, and egg curd foundation.

Cook until thickened in a double-boiler. Fill the crust with the vivid cranberry and lime curd after integrating some butter and allowing it to cool for about two hours.

What Do You Eat On Thanksgiving In Your Family?

Turkey, stuffing, gravy, sweet potatoes, cornbread, mashed potatoes, and cranberry sauce are all traditional Thanksgiving meals. Pie is commonly served as a dessert at the end of a meal, and Pumpkin, pecan, sweet potato, and apple are popular pie tastes. They describe a feast of newly slaughtered deer, various wildfowl, a bountiful supply of cod and bass, and flint, a native maize type gathered by Native Americans and used to make cornbread and porridge.


The best Thanksgiving pie recipes are not limited to traditional apple or pumpkin pies. You can create a no-bake pie or a gluten-free pie. If you’re having a Thanksgiving dinner with relatives, it’s nice to make a homemade pie that everyone in the family will enjoy. The best Thanksgiving pie recipes are easy to prepare, and you can start by searching online for the ingredients you need. Thanksgiving pie recipes are essential for a successful holiday. While you may be able to make pumpkin pies for the occasion, you might also want to consider making an apple or pecan pie. Among the most popular Thanksgiving pies are the ones with pumpkin and apple.

Aside from the pumpkin pie, you may also want to try some fruit pies. While the classic apple pie is a great option, you can also try a vegan pie if you prefer. The best Thanksgiving pie recipes should also be easy to, and they should be easy to make and don’t require a lot of ingredients. Whether you use a pre-made crust or make your own, it will be easy to prepare these recipes. For extra special Thanksgivingcipes, see which ones work best for you. You’ll be glad you did! You’ll be surprised by the variety of flavors and textures you’ll be able to find.